30 Comments
User's avatar
тна Return to thread
Florida Man's avatar

William F Buckley Jr wrote a compelling book titled In Search of Antisemitism. His conclusion was that Pat Buchanan is indeed an antisemite.

Expand full comment
Ronald Traynor's avatar

William F. Buckley was installed by the CIA. Not an honest man.

Expand full comment
Raincheck's avatar

Buckley was raised speaking Esperanto for 10 years before he learned English. There were times that not even he knew what he meant.

Expand full comment
Florida Man's avatar

No, William F. Buckley Jr. did not grow up speaking Esperanto. He grew up speaking Spanish as his first language, as his family lived in Mexico during his early years. He learned French when he attended school in Paris and only began learning English at age seven when his family moved to London. There is no credible evidence suggesting that Esperanto was part of his upbringing.

Expand full comment
Raincheck's avatar

You're kind of locked in on literal aren't you?

Expand full comment
Florida Man's avatar

Absolutely. I live in Reality.

Expand full comment
Raincheck's avatar

He still doesn't get it. Oh well...

Expand full comment
Florida Man's avatar

No, if youтАЩre so smart please explain it to me.

Expand full comment
Ronald Traynor's avatar

The guy was a turd!

Expand full comment
Ronald Traynor's avatar

Buckley's role was to muddy the water and conceal truth.

Expand full comment
David Baltz's avatar

Joe Sobran, one of the finest minds at National Review, wrote a few articles somewhat critical of Israel. WFB fired Joe Sobran after waning him that "you can't offend those people!" Buckley was very conscious of where the money for National Review came from.

Expand full comment
Florida Man's avatar

William F. Buckley Jr. was deeply sensitive to the issue of anti-Semitism, as evidenced by his landmark essay and subsequent book, In Search of Anti-Semitism. In this work, Buckley scrutinized the writings of several figures, including Joseph Sobran, a longtime colleague and friend. While Buckley did not explicitly label Sobran an anti-Semite, he concluded that SobranтАЩs тАЬtendentiousтАЭ focus on Israel and related topics could reasonably lead others to perceive him as such.

BuckleyтАЩs handling of the matter was nuanced. He dissociated himself from SobranтАЩs writings on Jews, Judaism, and Israel but acknowledged SobranтАЩs broader contributions to National Review. This careful approach reflected BuckleyтАЩs commitment to combating anti-Semitism while maintaining intellectual fairness.

Given BuckleyтАЩs rigorous examination of the issue and his reluctance to make accusations lightly, his concerns about Sobran likely had a legitimate basis, even if they stopped short of outright condemnation.

Expand full comment
David Baltz's avatar

It is unfortunate that anyone criticizing Israel in any way, is immediately labeled anti-Semitic. When Israel claimed that John Demjanjuk was Ivan the Terrible, Buchanan came to his defense. This was all it took (besides being a traditional Catholic) to label Buchanan an anti-Semite. Buchanan persisted in Demjanjuk's defense and, in the end, it turned out he was right. John Demjanjuk had been falsely accused and the courts overturned his conviction. Regrettably, Buchanan's 'conviction in the press' of anti-Semitism was never overturned.

Expand full comment
Florida Man's avatar

There is still to this day no conclusion to the conviction in Germany. John Demjanjuk died before his appeal for his conviction was overturned so he remained innocent under German law. ItтАЩs not just BuchananтАЩs defense of him, but some of his rhetoric about details of the death camps and gas chambers that drew accusations of antisemitism and Holocaust revisionism .

Expand full comment